Hi everybody– This video is for all of you out there who have nightmares about frosting square cakes! I hope that you’ll find a tip or two that will make the process much less intimidating.
The truth is, frosting a square cake with buttercream is not difficult if you have a good method– but it is definitely more time consuming than frosting a round cake. There’s just no way around it (and so charge accordingly if you have a cake business!)
The more that you practice frosting square cakes, the more quickly things will come together–and if you follow the steps in this tutorial, you will be impressed with your square-caking skills in no time!
Make sure to check out additional information beneath the video–enjoy!
Details about our Square Cake
In this tutorial, I’m frosting a three layer White Almond Sour Cream (doctored mix) recipe– These are six inch cake layers. They have already been filled and settled prior to the start of the video.
Buttercream– I used our High Ratio recipe. I like crusting buttercreams and so any of ours would work well (High Ratio, Fluffy Vanilla, Classic Vanilla…). If you do not work with crusting buttercreams, you will still be able to use the most important tips in this tutorial–but you will not be able to use the Viva Paper Towel method for smoothing, as I do in the end.
Foam Core Board slightly larger than your cake– My board was about ¼ inch larger than my cake on all sides. A thickness of ½ inch is a good choice. The thicker boards are less likely to bend under the weight of your cake when you move them, and it’s also a good thickness for guiding your bench scraper.
Bench Scraper– I like a bench scraper with a curled handle like THIS ONE. It doesn’t have to look exactly like this, but it’s best if the handle doesn’t extend past the edge.
Pot of Hot Water — * With Swiss Meringue buttercreams, very hot spatulas can cause color streaking–so, do a test patch on a plate to be sure. If your color streaks, skip the hot knife step (but you can still chill your cake in between frosting applications)
Viva Paper Towel– Optional, but I like the “Viva Method” as a finishing touch
Fondant Smoothers– Again, optional–but if you are using the Viva Method of smoothing for final touches, they are helpful
Miscellaneous~ I used a piece of food safe vinyl to cover my countertop (optional) to keep things clean. I used a larger cake board to transfer the cake to and from the freezer.
Notes
As I mentioned in the video, the most important part of the method is that you are using your cake board as your guide, as well as a bench scraper.
If your usual smoothing methods don’t match mine, that is fine. You can experiment with other ways of frosting your cakes–but I think that you’ll find that using a slightly larger board than your cake will help you to achieve those sharp corners even if the cake itself doesn’t have corners as sharp.
You will want to make more frosting than you will actually need. You can freeze the leftover frosting in an airtight container. The reason for the excess is that you will want to really build out your frosting, just past the cake board, so that when you go back with your bench scraper, the scraper will be in contact with frosting from bottom to top. Once that excess is scraped away, you’ll be left with a very smooth and even layer of frosting.
* There are other great methods out there for achieving sharp corners, and I encourage you to experiment with as many as you can. Cake decorating is all about finding what works best for you. This is what works best for me! I did not invent the method of using the board as a guide, and many of you will be familiar with it already–but for those who aren’t, I hope that you’ll give it a try! Let us know how it goes ;0)
Is there a place to order/buy the foam core board squares already cut to size you need? Afraid I will cut it and then that won’t be square! LOL
Hi Leane, this is a link to a site that will precut foam core to size, http://www.foamcoreheaven.com/. I would have the foam core be 1/4 to 1/2 inch thickness.
Also, anywhere that does framing has foam core and you could buy a sheet and have them cut you as many sizes as you would like from that one sheet.
Remember that your cake always shrinks a bit so keep that in mind when deciding the size of your square board. I don’t like a think layer of frosting, so when I am frosting a buttercream square cake, if it is a 6 inch cake my board is cut to six inches and with the shrinkage it is enough frosting for me.
Thanks so much! I was just thinking of me cutting foam board and the disaster that would follow! LOL Did not even think of a frame shop!
Leane thanks so much for your question, and BeBe thanks for the resource. I was wondering about this at well.
what brand of square pans do you use? how many people would a square cake feed if im doing 2 tiers… one 9 inch tier and one 6 inch tier with three layers each?
This is a great video Melissa and BeBe. I wish I had watched it prior to making the rainbow birthday cake in the rectangle shape which I posted a photo of in the “children’s” category. I had a heck of a time getting the edges sharp…they weren’t exactly, but did look ok :-/ Next time I make a rectangle cake I will use my bench scraper as I think your method would also apply to rectangles. Great video. Thank you.
Thanks so much for the info.
I’m having the most difficult time finding foam core any suggestions as to where I can find it
I bought a couple of sheets of foam core board from Michael’s. It is Elmer’s Brand. When we cut it the foam wrinkled and pulled on one of the sides. Could this be filled in with RI?
I am making 8-10 inch square cakes for my son’s wedding in August. Thanks so much for the timing on the tutorial. I am practicing a lot, since caking is a hobby for me, everyone gets square cakes til August.
Hi Sandy, I think that it could still be fine as it is. As you build out the ganache, if that is what you will be using I think that will fill in the rough edges and you should still be able to smooth with your bench scraper. The royal icing is a good idea but I think it would be fragile and break as you scrape, though I’m not sure. Let us know how it goes.
This video just proves that I have to increase my level of patience. That’s my problem, I never take all the time necessary. I find that I rush to get it done and it’s never this good :)
Hi Mimi– Yes…patience is key! ;0) Honestly, I do not always make my cakes with razor sharp edges- mine often have a softer look. But, since we see more and more of this look in cake land, I wanted to demonstrate how to do it! The most important thing is to remember is that square cakes are not only more servings than round, they take about twice as long to frost or cover. So, make sure to charge more for squares!
Thanks for another great video! I’ll have to get me a bench scraper!
Thanks Lisa, I’m glad that you liked it! (Love my bench scraper!) ;0)
Do you trim your cakes any? They look more “square” to begin with. Maybe I am using the wrong pans!
Hi Deanna, we like to use Magic Line pans because they have very sharp corners.
Do you not have to crumb the entire cake before frosting?
Hi Linda- It’s up to you. I often crumb coat my cakes before adding the final coat, however for this tutorial, I just built out my frosting layer by layer for each side until it met the foam core square. As long as your crumbs are contained within that first layer of frosting, you’ll be fine!
Thank you!
Hello ladies, I am making a suitcase cake for this weekend. Today, My question is: Would it be better to split each layer and frost between or just make 3 layers? I nevertrally knew the reason split layers but I have seen bakers do it. Please advise…thanks so much!!!
Hi Terri, we most often just bake the layers individually rather than splitting them. Now and then we may split if our layers are thick and we want additional layers of filling, but usually we do not.
Hello, any idea why the videos keep blacking out on me? These are the second, alternate videos. The first videos won’t even play for me. Any advice?
Hi Debbie, are you having this trouble with all of the videos, or just the ones on this post? Is today the first day you’ve experienced this? Hopefully whatever is causing this is temporary, as is often the case with viewing issues. (I can see both of these videos as usual from my end). But you could also try viewing on another device, or in another browser, or you could even check to make sure that nothing on your device or browser needs updating. Let us know if this continues! The best way to reach us is by e-mailing info@Mycakeschool.com– Thanks!!
Hi Melissa,
I haven’t been experiencing trouble with all of the videos, just certain ones on this site. Today is not the first time I’ve had trouble. I did notice that I did not have a problem on my cell phone (I was using my iPad before). I will try the other options that you mentioned. I was able to pull the video up a few days later. Hopefully it was just temporary. Thanks!